Core77

Could the Classic Orange Construction Barrier Use a Redesign?

Industrial designer Scott Henderson thinks city dwellers deserve better

By Emily Suzuki - June 17, 2019

in Urbanism | Object Culture | Solutions

Sometimes design opportunities are right in front of your very eyes. For instance, anyone living in an urban setting is familiar with the scene below:

The classic orange barrier (otherwise known as the plastic Jersey Barrier) is an iconic symbol of urban construction in the Big Apple, right up there with temporary green plywood walls marked "Post No Bills". Each plastic barrier is blow-molded and kept hollow to minimize weight during travel. Once placed at a construction site, they are then filled with water to ensure they stay put.

Even though they serve a noble purpose, the barriers are, without a doubt, a big, fat, orange eyesore to passerby and nearby dwellers. And if you live in any city, you're very familiar with the long lead times of construction projects—they often take anywhere from weeks to months to complete.

Brooklyn-based industrial designer Scott Henderson identified this design opportunity after walking past one too many ugly orange barriers in his neighborhood. "The city is always changing, and with that comes large scale construction projects that are surrounded by tens of thousands of these super ugly, construction barriers," says Henderson of his 'aha' moment. "It is clear to me that no one has ever considered these unsightly "Lego" blocks beyond their utilitarian purpose—like how they affect the lives of people forced to live around them."

So, he set out to do what any frustrated designer would do when confronted with an object in need of improvement: redesign. Recognizing that it would cost about the same amount of money to manufacture a more beautiful version of the orange barriers, Henderson went to work, eventually yielding the below solution:

Since the material is still plastic, the barriers could theoretically be any color, but we're digging the green. Below are a few more visualizations of what they would look like on site:

The lattice surface pattern makes the barriers more visually interesting while discouraging graffiti. Granted, the barriers would still be paired with a pretty ugly constriction site, but at least at eye level, the view would be much more pleasant.

Have you ever come across an urban object that could use an upgrade? Let us know in the comments.

o
1

Favorite This
Q
4

Comment

Comments

Christopher Hanks

5 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

This is perfectly in line with findings related to the Biophilia Effect I read about in Universal Principles of Design. This is the reason the wavy green barriers seem more appealing. The orange boundaries are an eyesore because they literally contribute to the stress of living in an urban environment. I totally agree that these new barriers are solving a real problem!
Green is good for you - https://www.apa.org/monitor/apr01/greengood
Green spaces reduce stress - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5981243/

!Report as spam
Scott Henderson

5 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

They do taper the same way- same width on base as Yodock and same with at top-but the rendering on the first image has exaggerated perspective so it looks straight- the 4th image down shows the wedge shape better. The idea for the concept was to highlight an “invisible until proven otherwise” design project.

!Report as spam
Ryan Spotowski

5 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

The redesigned barriers are missing out on two important features of the current models. The base of the barriers protrudes at an angle to help change the direction of the momentum of cars hitting the barrier. The second is that the tapered design also allows the barriers to nest when stacked so they can be easily stored and transported.

Going back to an article from May (https://www.core77.com/posts/88545/A-Triumph-of-Design%E2%80%94and-Manufacturing-The-Story-of-Cubipods-and-the-Innovative-Mold-Required-to-Make-Them?utm_source=core77&utm_medium=from_title, there is a benefit to simplicity in mold design.

!Report as spam
- Lance Craig
  
  Ryan Spotowski
  
  5 years ago
  
  Z
  
  Z
  
  Reply
  
  They're also Safety Orange for several reasons.
  
  !Report as spam