e
The Design Flaw of Boot Jacks, Part 2: Potential Solutions
Thanks to Tim Hines, Joshua Cooper and Ross Oliver
Earlier we looked at the design flaw of boot jacks, which is that you must step on a muddied object with a bare sock.
Enter a caption (optional)Many of the comments made incorrect assumptions and were unhelpful; the most ridiculous suggestion was that doormats--which we of course own and use--will remove 100% of mud from the bottom of a boot. (Surprise: They don't.)
Another unhelpful suggestion: Rinse the boots off each and every time. My wife and I live on a farm where it freezes overnight, yet gets warmer during the day. This recipe provides both mud and frozen hoses/pipes. Keeping an outdoor source of running water on hand is not an option.
Reader Tim Hines responded like a true designer, taking the problem at face value and proposing an actual solution:
Enter a caption (optional)Hines' intelligent approach widens the part of the jack that you brace with the other foot. Assuming you always take the boots off in a consistent order (i.e. left first or right first), this would provide one muddy corner and one clean corner, obviating the dirty sock problem. Smart.
Reader Joshua Cooper also had a neat idea: "I would suggest putting the fulcrum/leg on the top as well as the bottom. That way you could remove one boot, flip the jack over and remove the other boot."
Hines gamely illustrated Cooper's idea:
Enter a caption (optional)"Neat and compact," Hines added, "although you do have to bend down to turn it."
Reader Ross Oliver used his own experience to offer another idea (unillustrated):
"The heel-to-toe stance makes balance much more difficult. I sometimes remove my shoes by standing the toe of one on the heel of the other, and I almost always need to lean on something for balance. I would mount the jack to a base 3x as wide, and stand feet side-by-side to use. Solves the sock soiling problem too."
During the traditional design process, these three ideas would receive additional refinement, going through multiple iterations; they are not perfect as is. But they both demonstrate solid design thinking and are a great start. They were also fun to read, as they remind me of the brainstorming process at actual ID firms. Thanks to Hines, Cooper and Oliver for taking the time to sound off!
-
oFavorite This
-
Q10Comment
Directory Company Profiles
Core77
Industrial Design
Resources
Industrial Design
Resources
-
Core77 Directory
Find the Best Industrial Design CompaniesGo -
Formation Design Group
Formation is a product design + development company focused on human centered design innovation. To ...
-
Fresco Design
Fresco supports world-class brands with world-class design. Based in the Boston area, a leading inno...
-
Speck Design
Speck Design is a Silicon Valley product design and strategy consultancy. For twenty years Speck Des...
-
Bluemap Design
BlueMap design is a multi-disciplinary product development firm. Founded by Simon Yan in 2001, the f...
-
Open Design
We partner with teams to deliver fresh thinking and award winning products for passionate audiences....
-
Olivialand Studio
Olivialand Studio, founded by Olivia Blechschmidt, is a boutique industrial design consultancy that ...
-
Studio1642
Get the website and videos your business needs in weeks, not months. Enjoy personalized, high-qualit...
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
Comments
Bolt it to the floor I say.
Yeah, the more I think about this, the more I think that's the way to go.
Ok, ok, fine! I'll be helpful this time. Here's your answer. The handle is weighted, so it stays on one side until you flip it over with your foot. No bending down.
Also, there's a rubber wheel on the one point, to help with traction.
Or go all out, make it out of steel, and bolt the sucker to the floor.
Had to have a go at this!
How about a two footed arrangement? Stand on the base of the unit and lift either foot first and step out of the boot. Doesn't matter what order, and you never get a dirty sock...
Had to have a go at this!
How about a two footed arrangement? Stand on the base of the unit and lift either foot first and step out of the boot. Doesn't matter what order, and you never get a dirty sock...
I had to try making this and realised that the two triangles cut off the side make good supports. It works well and is very stable. I was contemplating putting a strip of carpet or just a raised panel in the centre for sock usage, leaving both outer edges for the muddy boot usage, thus not requiring consistent boot removal order!
We need two surfaces, a boot and a sock surface. They could be managed with a hinged element that is either sprung up or lifted to a holding detent. I'd make the boot portion the fixed bottom and the sock surface the top. You'd want different surfaces to indicate the intended use of each.
A doormat wont suffice. The first thing you need is a boot scraper.