e
When the Design of an Object Doesn't Consider How It's Meant to be Stored
Or, objects you've never thought about: Crowd control stanchion storage carts
Nowadays "crowd control" makes me think of teargas and rubber bullets, but in more peaceful times, the term encompasses an ecosystem of products related to queue formation. Banks, airports, nightclubs and event spaces all have closets full of stanchions, ready to be deployed as traffic increases.
The main job of a stanchion is to support its velvet rope or seatbelt-thingy without falling over, so many of them still have cast iron bases supporting heavy steel posts. Standard 36" tall stanchions can weigh 25 pounds apiece, so asking a worker to fetch and deploy a dozen of them isn't trivial. The bases can be over a foot in diameter, so plopping them all down on a standard moving dolly would be terribly space-inefficient.
For this reason stanchion storage carts exist, where the designer is tasked with storing these oddly-shaped, heavy items in a space-efficient manner. Manufacturer Visiontron produces this metal cart that stores them horizontally, keeping the footprint minimal. They come in both 12- and 24-stanchion capacities and cost $485 (12-unit capacity) to $720 (24-unit capacity).
The design is fairly brutish, and loading/unloading one of these looks to be an unergonomic experience. I felt a smarter design was this alternative, below, that's based on a standard moving dolly and stores the posts vertically. To get around the footprint problem, they've added these ziggurat-like folded metal sheets that allow you to stagger the bases:
You can also pop the staggering contraption off, and use it like a regular dolly:
The trade-off is that this design only stores 18 units--yet costs more, at $813, than the 24-unit horizontal storage model above. It also has nearly double the footprint of the 24-unit model. That being the case, if I'm in charge of procurement and don't care about my facility workers' back pain, I'm going to order the 24-unit models and avoid making eye contact with Ronald and Smitty when they're on-shift.
I think the problem here is with the design of the stanchions themselves, which appears only to consider their use in the deployed position; little consideration has been given to where they "live" when not in use. I believe that's a common problem across a wide spectrum of objects, and I'd love to see a design school where this is addressed in their methodology.
-
o1Favorite This
-
Q2Comment
Directory Company Profiles
Core77
Industrial Design
Resources
Industrial Design
Resources
-
Core77 Directory
Find the Best Industrial Design CompaniesGo -
Mighty Studios
Mighty Studios is a business-savvy product design consultancy. We believe that good design should be...
-
studioFAR
Established in 2009, studioFAR is a softgoods design firm based in the Mission district of San Franc...
-
Shark DesignShark Design is a full service product development company with offices in Hong Kong, Shenzhen (Chin...
-
Speck Design
Speck Design is a Silicon Valley product design and strategy consultancy. For twenty years Speck Des...
-
Tactile
Tactile is a product and UX design firm founded in 2004. Blending physical and digital design, we cr...
-
Spatial Dynamics
Spatial Dynamics is a hardware product design and development agency located in Cambridge, Massachus...
-
Architectural Cladding & Roofing
Architectural Cladding & Roofing (ArcClad) are a New Zealand based firm specializing in roofing prod...
K
{Welcome
Create a Core77 Account
Already have an account? Sign In
By creating a Core77 account you confirm that you accept the Terms of Use
K
Reset Password
Please enter your email and we will send an email to reset your password.
Comments
So back to the stanchions. The first obvious step is consider removing the posts from bases when they are stowed. This poses a follow on question: does the process of attaching / detaching poles to posts slow down the deployment / stowage of the stanchions? Asking workers to pick up the heavy poleless bases from the floor is no good - risk of finger and back injuries.
It was addressed in my design school - under the title of Offline Considerations (that's Offline in the sense of an object not being in active use). It would also consider issues surrounding the steps between Online and Offline (i.e, a vacuum cleaner will need its power cable to be stowed before its put away.