Core77

Which Face Masks are Most/Least Effective?

A Duke University study ranks them in order

By Rain Noe - August 10, 2020

With everyone wearing different styles of facemasks, Duke University physician and professor Eric Westman wondered: Are each mask-sellers' claims of efficacy true? Which masks are the most effective, and which simply provide a false sense of security?

As reported by Duke Health, Westman's colleague Martin Fischer, the chemist and physicist in charge of Duke's Advanced Light Imaging and Spectroscopy facility, devised a scientific test using a laser. Subjects spoke through a variety of masks, and the airborne droplets that made it through the mask were counted.

Types of Masks Tested (Not Ranked, Just Numbered)

1. 'Surgical' (Surgical mask, 3-layer)

2. 'Valved N95' (N95 mask with exhalation valve)

3. 'Knitted' (Knitted mask)

4. 'PolyProp' (2-layer polypropylene apron mask)

5. 'Poly/Cotton' (Cotton-polypropylene-cotton mask)

6. 'MaxAT' (1-layer Maxima AT mask)

7. 'Cotton 2' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

8. 'Cotton 4' (2-layer cotton, Olson style mask)

9. 'Cotton 3' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

10. 'Cotton 1' (1-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

11. 'Fleece' (Gaiter type neck fleece)

12. 'Bandana' (Double-layer bandana)

13. 'Cotton 5' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

14. 'Fitted N95' (N95 mask, no exhalation valve, fitted)

'Swath' (Swath of mask material, polypropylene)

'None' (Control experiment, no mask)

Test Results

Enter a caption (optional)

The most surprising result is that wearing the fleece mask was worse than wearing no mask at all. As Fischer explains, the fleece essentially serves as an aerator on a sink faucet--it not only lets the droplets through, but breaks them up into finer droplets, allowing them to remain in the air longer.

Finally, for clarity's sake, we've arranged the images of the masks in order of efficacy.

Mask Types Ranked in Order of Efficacy:

Ranked #1

14. 'Fitted N95' (N95 mask, no exhalation valve, fitted)

Ranked #2

1. 'Surgical' (Surgical mask, 3-layer)

Ranked #3

5. 'Poly/Cotton' (Cotton-polypropylene-cotton mask)

Ranked #4

4. 'PolyProp' (2-layer polypropylene apron mask)

Ranked #5

(Not pictured) 'Swath' (Swath of mask material, polypropylene)

Ranked #6

13. 'Cotton 5' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

Ranked #7

7. 'Cotton 2' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

Ranked #8

2. 'Valved N95' (N95 mask with exhalation valve)

Ranked #9

8. 'Cotton 4' (2-layer cotton, Olson style mask)

Ranked #10

6. 'MaxAT' (1-layer Maxima AT mask)

Ranked #11

10. 'Cotton 1' (1-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

Ranked #12

9. 'Cotton 3' (2-layer cotton, pleated style mask)

Ranked #13

3. 'Knitted' (Knitted mask)

Ranked #14

12. 'Bandana' (Double-layer bandana)

Ranked #15

'None' (Control experiment, no mask)

Ranked #16

11. 'Fleece' (Gaiter type neck fleece)

So yeah, if you see someone in the store wearing a fleece mask, probably better to steer clear.

o

Favorite This
Q
6

Comment

Comments

Austin Jarvis

4 years ago

Z

1Z

Reply

This study does not rank which masks are most/least effective. The authors clearly laid this out multiple times in the original study:
"Again, we want to note that the mask tests performed here (one speaker for all masks and four speakers for selected masks) should serve only as a demonstration. Inter-subject variations are to be expected, for example due to difference in physiology, mask fit, head position, speech pattern, and such."
The authors were in the Physics department and were just trying to create a cheap and easy methodology that could be used to analyze masks. They haven't actually done the analyzation.

!Report as spam
Mark Hollister

4 years ago

Z

1Z

Reply

I'm not a statistician, but isn't it technically improper to rank the masks in this manner since many of the masks have mean and standard deviations so close to each other as to have no statistically significant difference? For example, the Valved N95 and Cotton 4 mask have mean values really close to each other and their standard deviations both encompass each others means, such that we can't really know based on this test design if one of them is really any better than the other due to the variability? Again, I'm not a statistician, but instead ranking them by groups of masks with similar effectiveness levels may be more accurate.

!Report as spam
Jose Gonzalez

4 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

Thanks for the breakdown. I wish the study would have specified if the cotton was of the “tightly woven” kind. I recently acquired a cotopaxi 2-layer which claims to use tight weave cotton.

!Report as spam
George Mokray

4 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

My bandana mask has 9 layers plus a vacuum cleaner bag material filter since I've read that that material is one of the best filter materials and a wire frame to hug to my face and keep my glasses unfogged..

Here's how to make one
https://youtu.be/eVPBQczb9gI

!Report as spam
Mark H

4 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

Wow, the valved masks aren't as sociopathic as they seemed.

!Report as spam
Juan Cano

4 years ago

Z

Z

Reply

Dang it, I wear the gaiter strechy material one. It's so much more comfortable than anything else. But I guess I'm not helping anyone.

!Report as spam